Defending People

the tao of criminal defense trial lawyering

Reptiles Revisited: Lizards Don’t Label

Mark Bennett | March 2, 2010

It turns out that insurance defense lawyers are putting at least some effort into finding new ways to try cases. They have a magazine, For the Defense, and an associated blog (sadly uncommented-on). Kathy Cochran, writing on the blog, takes note of David Ball and Don Keenan’s Reptile:

This book posits that jurors must be convinced [...]

The Anthony Graves Retrial Pregame Show

Mark Bennett | February 12, 2010

In Anthony Graves’s first trial, prosecutor Charles Sebesta had to cheat to win, hiding exculpatory evidence and eliciting perjured testimony (Graves v. Dretke, Fifth Circuit opinion, PDF on Scribd).
Now, not only has the evidence that Sebesta suppressed in violation of Brady v. Maryland been revealed so that the next prosecutor trying the case can’t continue [...]

Punishing the Prosecutor to Fit the Crime

Mark Bennett | February 12, 2010

A Harris County felony prosecutor, in closing argument, says (PDF on Scribd):
You-all heard some evidence, which I would have loved to brought you more people, but I couldn’t. This case is, does Harris County find what he did okay? And I still don’t know what he did, because he won’t even say it.
We all say [...]

Roeder, Padilla, Terry, Mohammed Part 1:Roeder

Mark Bennett | February 3, 2010

On April 16th, 1995 (three days before the highly-significant-to-militias April 19th anniversary of the Oklahoma City Bombing and the burning of the Branch Davidian Compound in Waco), Scott Roeder was arrested with bomb-making materials.
Roeder claimed association with the “Freemen” movement, yet another batch of personal sovereignty kooks.
On May 31, 2009, Scott Roeder shot down [...]

Read This Today

Mark Bennett | February 3, 2010

In this morning’s Houston Chronicle, criminal defense lawyer (and HCCLA ex-president, and former U.S. Navy officer) Pat McCann asks, Since When are Americans Afraid of Trials?
Those who are caught in the act of a crime or afterward and can be prosecuted in our justice system, however, should be prosecuted. There is no simpler way to [...]

The Four Most Powerful Words in the Criminal Courthouse

Mark Bennett | January 22, 2010

Try this:
Stand up. Raise one foot off the ground. Now shift your weight forward. Don’t set your raised foot down. What happens?
You fall down.
But if you do the same thing and set the raised foot down  to stop your fall, you take a step. Raise the other foot off the ground, shift your weight forward, [...]

Case Oddity

Mark Bennett | October 8, 2009

Here’s a picture from Harris County’s 263rd District Court yesterday. The prosecutors trying a murder (?) case had laid down a blue tape outline of the dead person’s body, chalk-outline style, early in the trial:
When I saw this, my first reaction was: awesome! (coincidentally, that was my nine-year-old’s reaction as well). The prosecutors, Brad Hart [...]

In Support of the Nudge

Mark Bennett | January 11, 2009

New York criminal defense lawyer Scott Greenfield and I usually agree on things, and he’s a lot older and somewhat wiser than me (though still spry), so when he seems to disagree with me I take a careful look to see if maybe I’m wrong.
The client charged with a crime has three (in Texas, four) [...]

Ladies of the Jury, Opposing Counsel is Just Like You . . . Except that She’s Much More Successful

Mark Bennett | November 21, 2008

When I read articles about quirks of human behavior, I try to think of how I can take advantage of them both defensively and offensively. For example, when I read an article (from the American Society of Trial Consultants’ The Jury Expert magazine) entitled How We Can Help Witnesses Remember More, I consider not only [...]

I Want Angry Jurors With Low Self-Esteem

Mark Bennett | November 19, 2008

I’ve started reading the quarterly magazine of the American Society of Trial Consultants, The Jury Expert. It’s right up Defending People readers’ alley; it’s even subtitled “The Art and Science of Litigation Advocacy. I downloaded a stack of issues to carry in my bag for quiet times; there are several treasures in each volume. If [...]