Defending People

the tao of criminal defense trial lawyering

Ego

Mark Bennett | July 23, 2008

A Harris County prosecutor today (perennially gruff but a marshmallow on the inside) took umbrage at my public statements that until very recently I hadn’t seen a Harris County prosecutor conduct a voir dire that was worth a damn. I invited him to tell me when he was picking a jury, and I’d come watch [...]

Trial Psychosis

Mark Bennett | July 14, 2008

I can win this trial. I can! I can!

In Trial*

Mark Bennett | July 14, 2008

I’m in trial* on a white-collar criminal case. It is not an easy case, but sometimes we have to try the tough cases.
I’ve got to wonder why the prosecutor left on the jury two jurors who admitted that they couldn’t consider the top end of the statutory punishment range (i.e. life in prison). Maybe he [...]

Survival Situations: What’s at Risk?

Mark Bennett | June 19, 2008

I wrote last month about Laurence Gonzales’s Deep Survival: Who Lives, Who Dies, and Why and promised “much more later.” It occurs to me that the start of scavenging Gonzales’s work for criminal trial lawyers has to be relating survival to a criminal trial.
When Gonzales is talking about survival situations, he’s not referring only to [...]

Based on Actual Facts

Mark Bennett | June 18, 2008

Suppose that you were a prosecutor prosecuting a first-time DWI case, and that I was defending it.
Suppose further that the accused’s husband, an ex-cop, watched her performing the field sobriety tests at the scene, and would testify that she did fine. That the arresting officer claimed that his in-car video camera wasn’t working. That the [...]

You’re Not Listening!

Mark Bennett | March 4, 2008

Listen:
If you are a private lawyer, you can get more people to hire you.
If you are a court-appointed lawyer, you can help your clients appreciate you more.
You can pick a better jury.
You can demolish your adversary’s case.
You can perform a better direct examination.
You can perform a better cross-examination.
You can be happier in your relationship; you [...]

The Loss of Meaning

Mark Bennett | March 3, 2008

Scott Greenfield has apparently been having a blawgospheric discussion with Doug Berman about the merits of a Kentucky bill, HB210, that, in Doug’s words, “imagines forfeiture as a possible alternative (rather than an addition) to lengthening prison terms for certain offenders.”
After some back-and-forth in comments to Scott’s thorough critique of the idea of asset forfeiture [...]

Mexico Discovers Due Process

Mark Bennett | March 1, 2008

Mexico is in the process of overhauling its criminal justice system (WSJ). Jury trials aren’t in the works, yet, but reforms include a move from an inquisitorial system in which judges decide cases in secret based on written submissions, to an adversarial system of open trials with oral argument.
Oh, and now people accused of crimes [...]

Faith-Based Legal Argument

Mark Bennett | February 25, 2008

The same sorts of questions, it seems, pop up over and over again where lawyers gather to discuss the law. Questions like:
“Isn’t it a violation of the disciplinary rules for a lawyer to talk to another lawyer’s client about taking his case?”
and
“Shouldn’t I put my client on the stand, so that I can make a [...]

Trial Again Tomorrow

Mark Bennett | February 25, 2008

Knowing that a bunch of Harris County prosecutors are reading sometimes cramps my blogging style. I’ve got a felony cocaine and heroin case (less than a gram of each) set for trial tomorrow, and I feel constrained to say nothing more at this point than this:
It’s an automatic-probation case if we lose, but my client, [...]