Do I Need an Appellate Lawyer in My City?

You usually do not need a lawyer in your city for a direct appeal or a petition for discretionary review, because the appellate court decides those cases on the written record and the briefs. The Texas Rules of Appellate Procedure do not require a lawyer to live or keep an office in the city where the trial took place or the court sits.

A lawyer in your city may be the better choice in one situation: when the judgment is less than 30 days old and no motion for new trial has been filed.

The court decides from a written record.

The appellate record “consists of the clerk’s record and, if necessary to the appeal, the reporter’s record.” Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 34.1. In a criminal case the clerk’s record ordinarily holds the indictment or information, any defense motion presented to the court and overruled, the judgment, and the notice of appeal. Rule 34.5(a). The reporter’s record holds the court reporter’s transcription of as much of the proceedings, and as many of the exhibits, as the parties designate. Rule 34.6(a)(1).

The lawyer studies that record and writes a brief from it. An appellant’s statement of facts “must be supported by record references,” and the argument must have “appropriate citations to authorities and to the record.” Rule 38.1(g), (i). The justices can check each statement of fact against the page it cites.

Lawyers file these papers electronically.

Attorneys in criminal cases “must electronically file documents except for good cause shown in a motion filed in the appellate court.” Rule 9.2(c)(1). The filing goes through the electronic filing manager established by the Office of Court Administration. Rule 9.2(c)(2). A lawyer files in the same way from any city.

A court may decide a case without oral argument.

In the court of appeals, a party who has filed a brief, and has timely requested argument, may argue the case unless the court decides after examining the briefs that argument is unnecessary for one of four listed reasons. Rule 39.1. One of those reasons is that “the facts and legal arguments are adequately presented in the briefs and record.” Rule 39.1(c). The clerk’s notice tells the parties whether the court will allow argument; if it will, the notice gives “the location of the argument or instructions for joining the argument electronically.” Rule 39.8(a), (c)(2). Oral argument “should emphasize and clarify the written arguments in the briefs.” Rule 39.2.

In the Court of Criminal Appeals, “[o]ral argument will be permitted only in cases designated by the Court of Criminal Appeals.” Rule 75.1. If the Court permits argument, each side ordinarily has at most 20 minutes. Rule 75.3. If the Court grants review, the petitioner files a brief within 30 days, and the opposing party files one within 30 days after the petitioner’s brief is filed. Rules 70.1, 70.2.

Where does each stage happen?

Stage Where the work happens Does being local help?
Investigating for a motion for new trial, within 30 days of the judgment Wherever the witnesses and records are Probably, if the lawyers are otherwise equal, because the time to gather proof is short.
Hearing on a motion for new trial The local trial court Usually not, because a lawyer from another city can handle most hearings.
Briefing in the court of appeals The lawyer’s office, with electronic filing No, because the brief is written from the record, and filed electronically.
Oral argument in the court of appeals, if allowed The place or electronic connection named in the clerk’s notice No, because a lawyer can travel for the setting, or join electronically if the notice provides for it.
Petition for discretionary review The lawyer’s office, with electronic filing No, because the petition is a written filing.
Article 11.07 evidentiary hearing The local trial court No, because a lawyer from another city can handle most hearings.

A recent judgment can favor a lawyer in your city.

If the judgment is less than 30 days old and no motion for new trial has been filed, a lawyer in your city may be the better choice, all else being equal. A motion for new trial must be filed within 30 days after sentence is imposed. Rule 21.4(a). A lawyer near the courthouse may be better placed to carry out the investigation that makes the motion meaningful: finding the witnesses and gathering the affidavits in the time that remains.

What should you check when you choose a lawyer?

Three questions will tell you who will do the work and what that lawyer has done:

  • Is the lawyer board certified in criminal appellate law? The Texas Board of Legal Specialization awards that certification. Our page on board certification explains what it requires.
  • Has the lawyer handled cases in your court of appeals? Ask to see opinions and briefs from that court.
  • Who will write the brief? Ask for that lawyer’s name, and ask to see a brief that lawyer wrote.

We also have a page on what to consider before you hire a criminal-appeal lawyer.

Mark Bennett handles criminal appeals throughout Texas.

Mark Bennett is Board Certified in both Criminal Law and Criminal Appellate Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization—one of fewer than fifty Texas defense lawyers holding both certifications—and handles criminal appeals throughout Texas from Houston. To ask about a case, email us at [email protected], or use our contact form. Tell us the county and the date of the sentence.